How To Respond to a Low Settlement Offer in Atlanta

In Atlanta, car accident victims are entitled to compensation (settlement sum) from the at-fault party. The fault party’s insurance carrier handles the negotiation with the victim and offers them the settlement sum. Sometimes, and more often than not, insurance companies provide a low settlement offer to the victim.

While the amount is justifiable in some instances, it isn’t in others. Thus, it is crucial for Atlanta accident victims to know how to respond when faced with a low settlement sum. If you get a low settlement offer, our Atlanta car accident lawyers can represent you and fight for the maximum compensation.

Why Do Insurance Companies Make Low Settlement Offers? 

Indeed, insurance companies are always after their bottom line, which affects compensation sums. However, there are times when they have valid reasons for offering you a low settlement sum. One of such reasons is the lack of adequate information, like medical bills and records of other damages.

This is why you must ensure the insurance adjuster has all the information they need while investigating your accident. If you find that the offer you got was based on incomplete information, provide the adjuster with additional information to redo the offer. A fair settlement should reflect all your medical needs, from physical therapy to surgery.

Another reason for a low settlement offer is if you didn’t suffer severe injuries or extensive property damage. Here, a person with catastrophic injuries or whose car gets totaled would get a higher offer than someone in a minor car accident. If a person with catastrophic wounds gets a low settlement offer, then it is clear the insurance company is acting in bad faith. Your Atlanta injury attorney can reject the offer at this point and file a lawsuit.

Furthermore, the insurance adjuster can make a low offer if you have a pre-existing health condition. In addition, unexplained gaps in your medical history can also get you a low-ball settlement. The only way to combat the two is by disproving that the existing condition worsened your injuries and filling in the missing gaps.

How Do You Know if a Settlement Is Fair?

An experienced lawyer understands average car accident settlement amounts for various injuries and will fight for the maximum compensation.

We’ve prepared a personal injury settlement calculator that can provide an estimate of what your case may be worth. However, every case is different, and it’s best to speak with a skilled attorney about your situation.

How Do You Respond to a Low Settlement Offer? 

Getting a low settlement offer when you expect more can anger you and make you take the wrong steps. You should keep your cool and take the following steps to get what you deserve:

  • Analyze the Offer

Getting hot-headed and emotional will not help you get the settlement you deserve. As such, you need to maintain a level head and analyze the offer. Go through it with a fine-tooth comb, and note the reasons why the fault party’s insurer sent such an offer.

Also, if the low settlement sum is the first offer you’re getting, it means the insurance company is testing the water. They are looking to see if you will cave in or negotiate for more. So, at this point, you have to take this next step.

  • Ask Questions

Once you’ve analyzed the offer, it’s time to ask questions. Find out if it’s the last offer, and there’s room for negotiations, or if it’s the only offer you’ll receive from the insurer. If it’s the latter, ask the insurance adjuster why they made a low settlement offer. You can ask for a breakdown.

The adjuster is obligated to give you the reason for the low-ball sum. Note their response and use it in your counter-response. If, for instance, they cite insufficient evidence, provide them with more facts. When asking questions, you can do so in person or respond in writing.

  • Create a Counteroffer

When faced with a low settlement offer, you have to come up with another, but it must be within reason. It simply means that you cannot counter with an unreasonable high sum. You need to consider the amount you think you deserve and make an offer between that sum and what the insurer offered.

For example, the insurance adjuster offered you $20,000, but you feel you deserve $40,000. Since the offer came after the adjuster considered the limit of the fault party’s coverage, a good counteroffer would be between $30,000 and $35,000.

  • Don’t Settle Until You Heal Completely

If you received the low settlement offer while still undergoing treatment, do not accept it. Wait until you’re fully healed and have tallied the cost of treatment before accepting an offer. This way, you do not cheat yourself, and you get what you deserve.

Get Help From an Atlanta Car Accident Lawyer!

If you commence an insurance claim without a lawyer, you’ll likely get a low settlement offer. But with an expert auto accident attorney from The Weinstein Firm, you can be sure you’ll get the maximum compensation. Let us help you get what you deserve by scheduling a free consultation with us today.

Read More Related Articles

Truck Driver Fatigue and Trucking Accidents
Truck Accidents

How Lawyers Prove Truck Driver Fatigue

Truck Driver Fatigue and Its Role in Serious Accidents Truck driver fatigue is one of the most dangerous factors on Georgia roads. Fatigued drivers behind the wheel of large trucks

Geico Settlement Payouts Concept
Car Accidents

How Does Geico Determine Settlement Payouts?

Geico Settlement Payouts: What Georgia Accident Victims Need to Know If you were injured in a car accident and the at fault driver is insured by Geico, understanding how Geico

Average Payout for Rear-End Collision Concept, Rear-End Car Crash
Auto Accidents

What Is the Average Payout for a Rear-End Collision?

Understanding Rear-End Collision Settlements in Georgia Rear-end collisions are some of the most common car accidents across Georgia. These crashes range from minor fender benders to severe crashes that cause