What Is Circumstantial Evidence in an Atlanta Accident Case?

circumstantial evidence

Evidence in car accident lawsuits is something very crucial. This is because personal injury cases are civil, and as a general rule, “he who asserts must prove.” So, the strength of your evidence — as a plaintiff or defendant — determines if the balance of justice will tilt in your favor.

Circumstantial evidence is one of the types of evidence you need to prove the fault party’s negligence. If you’re wondering what it is, our Atlanta car accident lawyers break it down in this article. We will explain what this evidence type means and how it affects your injury claim.

What Is Circumstantial Evidence?

Generally, evidence in a car accident lawsuit is either direct or circumstantial. As the name implies, direct evidence proves a key contended fact. It is always present in any suit, whether criminal or civil, and it is easier to prove. It shows the liability or guilt of the fault party. Video footage of a driver running a red light is an excellent example of direct evidence.

Circumstantial evidence, also known as indirect evidence, is inferential proof. It does not directly link to any fact of the case, but you can infer by the surrounding circumstances. The inference is what leads to a conclusion, and most often, the decision is binding.

Some of the types of circumstantial evidence used in car accident cases include:

  • Photographs of the crash site
  • Diagrams showing how the accident happened
  • Images showing the damage to your car, as well as all the motor vehicles involved in the occurrence
  • Accident reconstruction report using diagrams or videos
  • Skidmark analysis

In the place of glaring direct proof, your Atlanta auto accident lawyer will use circumstantial evidence to connect the dot to prove a fact. Rather than being apparent, it is suggestive. It hints at the presence of a thing; it helps prove some point, and that’s why the court allows it.

Furthermore, unlike criminal trials where the proof is “beyond reasonable” doubt, it is different in civil lawsuits. In a civil case, the proof is on a “balance of probabilities.” It means that the court places the evidence on an imaginary scale, and the person whose evidence outweighs the other wins. This is why while circumstantial evidence is not enough to convict a defendant in a criminal trial, it is enough to win a car accident case.

How Do You Use Circumstantial Evidence in a Car Accident?

As already established, circumstantial evidence is helpful in auto accident lawsuits. It is most beneficial in a hit-and-run crash, where the fault driver flees the scene. In that instance, you need to collect evidence from the crash site to prove the fault of the hit-and-run driver. This is because the driver can deny being at the accident scene after identifying them.

Here, a piece of good circumstantial evidence is a dent on the fault driver’s car from the point of contact. Even if the driver comes up with an explanation for the damage, you can use accident reconstruction analysis to disprove their claim. Also, you can use GPS to show that the motorist was at the accident location.

All these pieces of circumstantial evidence standing alone cannot help your case. However, when evaluated together, they will collectively point to the liability of the fault driver. Thus, you need to be able to bring together several pieces of evidence to build your case.

Do You Need a Lawyer to Prove Circumstantial Evidence?

Indeed, you do not need a lawyer in a car accident case. You can handle it yourself and likely secure fair compensation. However, if your case heads into litigation, and you’re relying on circumstantial evidence, then you need to hire an Atlanta car accident lawyer.

An attorney knows how to gather and use circumstantial evidence. They have the experience needed to understand this evidence type and connect the dots to prove a point. Also, the experienced trial lawyer knows how to disprove the defendant’s assertions. In summary, with a lawyer, your chances of winning without direct evidence are higher, and they will get you the maximum compensation.

Contact Our Top Atlanta Car Accident Lawyers Today!

Every car accident lawsuit’s success depends on who has a stronger case, and evidence is a massive part of it. At The Weinstein Firm, our team of expert auto accident lawyers has successfully used circumstantial evidence to win cases for our clients. We will do the same if you give us a chance. We offer free case reviews and charge no upfront fees. So, call us to schedule a consultation.

Latest Posts

Intersection Accidents in Atlanta
What to Do After a Car Accident That’s Not Your Fault
Navigating Legal Claims after an Uber Accident: A Victim’s Guide
How Much Is My Kennesaw Car Accident Case Worth?
Get the compensation
you deserve $$$

Local Auto Accidents

  • Atlanta
  • Conyers
  • Decatur
  • Kennesaw
  • Lawrenceville
  • Morrow
  • Watkinsville

Stolen SUV chase with 10 kids aboard ends in crash; 4 flown to Atlanta   The Atlanta Journal Constitution [...]

10 kids involved in chase, crash in middle GA; 4 flown to Atlanta hospital in critical condition  WSB Atlanta [...]

1 killed in crash off I-75 in northwest Atlanta, police say  Atlanta News First [...]

One killed, another injured after car leaves roadway, crashes into tree: Atlanta Police  11Alive.com WXIA [...]

At least 11 killed on Georgia’s roads since start of holiday weekend  Now Habersham [...]

Decatur launches pace car program to slow down drivers and prevent pedestrian crashes  Decaturish.com [...]

Crash at notorious Decatur intersection sends three to the hospital  Decaturish.com [...]

1 dead in overnight Decatur car crash, police say  Atlanta News First [...]

1 dead in DeKalb County crash involving Tesla: Police  11Alive.com WXIA [...]

2 killed in multi-car crash in DeKalb County  WSB Atlanta [...]

Construction worker fatally injured on UGA campus; investigation underway  Online Athens [...]

Watkinsville woman killed in two-vehicle collision in Oconee County  Online Athens [...]

Truck driver killed, 3 others injured in related traffic accidents, Athens police say  Atlanta News First [...]

Watkinsville pedestrian killed in Athens while checking on another crash victim  Online Athens [...]

Family involved in fatal wreck after leaving North Georgia water park   The Atlanta Journal Constitution [...]

Best Personal Injury Lawyers In Atlanta, GA Of 2024  Forbes [...]

3 dead after driver flees from GA police, crashes vehicle as car goes up in flames  WSB Atlanta [...]

Clayton County: Stolen ambulance chase leads to crash near Tara Boulevard, Dixon Road  FOX 5 Atlanta [...]

Lanes blocked following multicar crash on I-75 in Clayton County  11Alive.com WXIA [...]

Teenage car break-in suspect in Gwinnett County struck by vehicle  FOX 5 Atlanta [...]

Woman killed after losing control of car on Barrett Parkway  Cobb County Courier [...]

WATCH: Drivers Allegedly Racing To Car Meet Wreck Each Other In 8-Car Pileup  Wonderful Engineering [...]

Drivers Allegedly Racing to Car Meet Wreck Each Other in 8-Car Pileup  The Drive [...]

5-year-old released from hospital after Bartow County crash that killed 5  11Alive.com WXIA [...]

Bartow County crash: KSU student laid to rest  11Alive.com WXIA [...]

Fatal Crash Blocks All Lanes On I-85 South In Gwinnett  Gwinnettdailypost.com [...]

At least 1 dead in major crash on I-85 South  FOX 5 Atlanta [...]

Motorcyclist hospitalized after crash with car near Gwinnett County Kroger  WSB Atlanta [...]

Several people hurt after SUV crashes into Gwinnett County Burger King  Atlanta News First [...]

Woman killed in Henry wreck that shut down I-75 South for hours   The Atlanta Journal Constitution [...]

Chikybombom suffers a serious car accident  MundoNOW [...]

Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in Georgia (Best Rates in 2024)  ValuePenguin [...]

Celebration of Life Service Set for Deeply-Loved Norcross Couple  Gwinnettdailypost.com [...]

Russell M. Jacoby  The Morning Call [...]

2 killed in motorcycle crash on I-20 in Rockdale County  WSB Atlanta [...]

Free Case Review
Weinstein law firm logo
Let's get started with your FREE consultation
Weinstein law firm logo
Injured in an Accident? You Want the Best!

When it comes to personal injury cases, time isn't always on your side. Contact us today and see why all of our clients say Weinstein Wins!

Let us fight for your rights and get you the maximum compensation you deserve!